You got bored with 210bhp supercharged version, but not with a 110bhp diesel version? different I suppose.
I guess we all have a different perception of how a car should be and feel. The only way is to test drive both yourself. No amount of wrangling here will really help you decide and if it does it could be the wrong choice for you. Get out there you lazy bugger
Pssst. Go supercharged.