| I've driven both on the track and they are quite different. The BMW is rear wheel drive, has a larger engine, a cockpit that feels cramped for space to me and an a less than pleasing style (for me) with the top up. When driving, looking over the long hood, the car felt larger and heavier than it actually is. The gearbox is good but not great, the engine power is adequate but not spectacular. If you want a BMW roadster, the Z4 is quite an improvement, the Porsche Boxster much better than either.
The MINI Cooper S hatch (I've not driven the convertible) is front wheel drive, has excellent handling, a surprisingly large interior for its size and a very nice six speed gearbox. The MINI is quick and tossable, the only way I can describe its character, the BMW doesn't come across this way- you have to purposely drive it to get it to respond. I hope that makes sense.
I'm not knocking the Z3, it's a nice car, but really different from the MINI, so its a matter of personal likes and dislikes. I would buy the MINI. |