[DeK]

Hello,

I launch a subject a little comparable with already open , I thought of a COOPER R56 or a COOPER R52 CABRIO, equipped well for the same price…

I already had a sold ONE Pack, and actualy a COOPER S1 63 and a COOPER S 170, it is to replace the S163 (from 06-2002...) with my wife…

it is not a question to regret the choice in 12 months, the COOPER R56 will be sold always well in a year to repurchase S175, I have little that the cabrio will have evil to be sold…

What would choose? the "innovation" or the cabrio???

thank you to argue your answers and escuse for my English...

[Tigger, Eeyore & Roo]

If I understand correctly:

You have an '02 and '05 Cooper S

You want to replace the '02 Cooper S with either a new Cooper or an old model Cooper Cabrio.

You think you might want to change to a new Cooper S later on and are concerned that re-selling the Cooper Cabrio might be difficult.

Hmmmm....

If you are not certain that you would want to keep the cabrio for a long time, I would keep both the current Cooper S's and look at the new Cooper S, after a year or two, when all of the initial problems have been sorted out.

Tigger.