Peugeot or BMW 1.6 - Which is better? - MINI Cooper Forum
Go Back   MINI Cooper Forum > Model Specific MINI Forums > MINI Cooper Diesel


MINI Cooper Diesel MINI Cooper Diesel 2007 - Present

Mini2.com is the premier Mini Cooper Forum on the internet. Registered Users do not see the above ads.
Reply
Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
2007 Cooper S "Timing Chain Tensioner Defect" igooba Australia 9 Aug 1st, 2014 02:01 PM
Oil Leak - 2006 Bmw Mini Cooper 1.6 Petrol LuciaMini Welcome New Members 2 Feb 26th, 2014 06:07 AM
2007 Cooper S "Timing Chain Tensioner Defect" igooba General Discussion 1 Feb 14th, 2014 09:40 AM
Special Offer BMW Enduro Mountain Bike chris@LloydBlackpool Lloyd Blackpool MINI 0 Dec 7th, 2012 01:23 PM
Special offer BMW Cruise bike chris@LloydBlackpool Lloyd Blackpool MINI 0 Dec 6th, 2012 03:15 PM

 
LinkBack Thread Tools Rate Thread
  #1 (permalink)  
Old Jun 26th, 2014, 11:17 AM
MINI2 Newbie
Offline
 
Join Date: Mar 2014
Posts: 28
Local Time: 08:29 PM
United Kingdom
Peugeot or BMW 1.6 - Which is better?

I skipped through some of the other thread re: the newer 1.6 Diesel engine used in the Mini.

2007 - 2009 is the Peugeot PSA 1.6 engine
2010 - 2013 is the newer BMW 1.6 engine
2014 onwards is the brand new 1.5

I have been hunting down a Dooper. Basically hovering around a 2009 or 2010 model with the right spec. So this made me wonder, is there any reason to get the BMW engine over the Peugeot one? Or is the older engine better?

Or just too nuanced for it to play any part of the buying decision?

Thanks
Reply With Quote
Sponsored Links
Advertisement
 
  #2 (permalink)  
Old Jun 26th, 2014, 12:39 PM
MINI2 Senior
Offline
 
Join Date: Sep 2011
Posts: 439
Local Time: 09:29 PM
Luxembourg Male
I've got the 2009 PSA engine in a Clubman. I'm at 130,000k with nothing but oil and filter changes. I get the stated 4.7L/100km fuel efficiency. I'm happy with the engine in this car. Still on the original battery too.

Some people have complained about the fuel comsumption figures on the BMW engine, but I have no long-term practical experience with that although I have driven both engines.

In terms of refinement, the BMW engine is much queter and smoother during the Stop/Start function. The PSA engine is a rather loud beast and not so gentle during the Stop/Start process.

If you are a DIY sort, then the PSA engine takes up less space in the engine bay and is easier to work on as a result. Should you need it there is lots of help on the Peugeot & Ford forums as the PSA is used in a wide variety of car makes.

Hope that helps.
Reply With Quote
  #3 (permalink)  
Old Jun 26th, 2014, 12:44 PM
MINI2 Newbie
Offline
 
Join Date: Mar 2014
Posts: 28
Local Time: 08:29 PM
United Kingdom
It does, thank you. Constant source of knowledge

Do you know if the 2010 1.6 BMW engine needs the turbo seal replacing, EGR cleaning, like in the Peugeot one?

I've only read positive things about the one you have to be honest, and noise doesn't bother me. The things like the turbo are simple. I was just curious as much as anything really.

I did read in that thread about the BMW not getting the same sort of MPG figures as quoted. Whereas all the 2007-2009 ones I've looked at are doing 60-70 through casual use. Not that it makes a huge difference, but the earlier Peugeot engine seems more consistent in that regard.
Reply With Quote
  #4 (permalink)  
Old Jun 26th, 2014, 01:11 PM
MINI2 Senior
Offline
 
Join Date: Sep 2011
Posts: 439
Local Time: 09:29 PM
Luxembourg Male
Turbo on the BMW engine is mounted down behind and not easy to access, unlike the PSA which is front-mounted. Never heard of anyone having to change the seals on the BMW engine or do the EGR - at least not on the forums. For the record, I'm at 130,000 with the PSA engine and have never cleaned the EGR...

I had a relatively serious and expensive issue with the clutch about 18 months after I bought the car, so it hasn't been completely trouble-free.

As regards the fuel consumption, mine was using more than quoted until I hit about 55,000km then it settled down to the quoted figures. When I bought it in 2009 it was giving me 5.1 or 5.2 L/100km.
Reply With Quote
  #5 (permalink)  
Old Jun 26th, 2014, 03:14 PM
MINI2 Newbie
Offline
 
Join Date: Mar 2014
Posts: 28
Local Time: 08:29 PM
United Kingdom
Interesting, thanks again!

Was your clutch issue predictable in any way, or just straight up unlucky?

I haven't read/heard of any known clutch issues, so I'm guessing you were just unlucky, sorry to hear that. Could I ask what it was? Was it thousands to sort out ?

I'd actually been hoping to get one with 35-45K on the clock, so if I do I guess it'll still need time to bed in.
Reply With Quote
  #6 (permalink)  
Old Jun 26th, 2014, 07:06 PM
MINI2 Senior
Offline
 
Join Date: Sep 2011
Posts: 439
Local Time: 09:29 PM
Luxembourg Male
At idle, the clutch was making a knocking noise when I first bought the car. I complained about it under warranty. Eventually the clutch started slipping. Mini covered the flywheel as a goodwill and offered some discounts on labour, but I still paid a tidy sum to have everything put in order. Came out to about €1400 total (after discounts). The story is all documented on this website - think the thread was "Clubman Clutch Despair" or something like that.

Since that episode, the car had performed beautifully, so I think it was just bad luck - likely a bad flywheel.
Reply With Quote
Sponsored Links
Advertisement
 
Reply


Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 
Thread Tools
Rate This Thread
Rate This Thread:

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
2007 Cooper S "Timing Chain Tensioner Defect" igooba Australia 9 Aug 1st, 2014 02:01 PM
Oil Leak - 2006 Bmw Mini Cooper 1.6 Petrol LuciaMini Welcome New Members 2 Feb 26th, 2014 06:07 AM
2007 Cooper S "Timing Chain Tensioner Defect" igooba General Discussion 1 Feb 14th, 2014 09:40 AM
Special Offer BMW Enduro Mountain Bike chris@LloydBlackpool Lloyd Blackpool MINI 0 Dec 7th, 2012 01:23 PM
Special offer BMW Cruise bike chris@LloydBlackpool Lloyd Blackpool MINI 0 Dec 6th, 2012 03:15 PM

» Hot Topics This Week
Naming your MINI? - (77 replies)
Power Steering Pump DIY - (53 replies)
Ok so who has ordered an F56 MCS? - (46 replies)
New Online Magazine for Track Day Enthusiasts - (23 replies)
Standard radio plays MP3? - (21 replies)
» Recent Threads
Which car would you choose?
Today 12:31 PM
by iSysman
Last post by iSysman
Today 06:46 PM
3 Replies, 132 Views
Stephen James, Enfield
Today 06:32 PM
Last post by Fuzionuk
Today 06:32 PM
0 Replies, 10 Views
TOTALLY BIZARRE! Help needed
Yesterday 09:17 PM
by Whale
Last post by Whale
Today 03:09 PM
6 Replies, 293 Views
New Owner - 2007 MCS (+JCW Kit)
Sep 10th, 2014 08:39 AM
Last post by pipster11
Today 12:01 PM
1 Replies, 245 Views
2014 MINI Cooper vs Ford Fiesta 1.0L
Jun 24th, 2014 02:41 PM
Last post by minifan90
Today 10:11 AM
5 Replies, 2,658 Views
Worldwide MINI Sales See Best July Ever in 2014
Aug 26th, 2014 05:40 PM
by mab01uk
Last post by minifan90
Today 09:25 AM
1 Replies, 455 Views
09 mini rear brake pad replacement
Sep 7th, 2014 07:02 PM
Last post by Hazel Green
Today 08:05 AM
3 Replies, 463 Views
Front bumper paint blistering
Dec 30th, 2012 09:46 PM
Last post by The Nun
Today 07:18 AM
6 Replies, 1,126 Views
No bite or stopping power after upgrade ebc
Today 04:38 AM
Last post by The Nun
Today 06:59 AM
1 Replies, 142 Views
Calibre Vintage 17 x 8
Sep 11th, 2014 06:40 PM
Last post by marque
Yesterday 10:18 PM
7 Replies, 525 Views
What sort of engine do i have ??
Sep 14th, 2014 09:58 PM
Last post by Minimissionone
Yesterday 09:15 PM
2 Replies, 340 Views
No power in 1st?
Yesterday 10:14 AM
Last post by marque
Yesterday 07:29 PM
2 Replies, 255 Views
Violent shakes when accelerating - goes away when I let go of pedal
Sep 1st, 2014 04:49 PM
Last post by Blusox
Yesterday 12:22 PM
7 Replies, 1,203 Views
Calling Siri or Google now...
Yesterday 11:35 AM
Last post by homeyjay
Yesterday 11:35 AM
0 Replies, 204 Views
Union Jack Badges
Yesterday 05:38 AM
Last post by The Nun
Yesterday 11:08 AM
1 Replies, 229 Views
N14/ N18 question
Aug 21st, 2014 01:04 PM
by oz1986
Last post by The Nun
Yesterday 08:07 AM
7 Replies, 725 Views
Standard radio plays MP3?
Nov 25th, 2004 12:39 PM
Last post by k3fus
Yesterday 06:05 AM
21 Replies, 10,392 Views
What issues?
Aug 24th, 2014 05:39 AM
by ben2012
Last post by MKuRNDY
Yesterday 03:39 AM
3 Replies, 635 Views
Lumbar Support & Seat Comfort
Nov 1st, 2011 03:18 PM
Last post by bwillett
Sep 14th, 2014 08:14 PM
6 Replies, 6,157 Views
» Premium
» Auto Insurance
Wheel & Tire Center

Powered by vBadvanced CMPS v3.2.1

All times are GMT. The time now is 07:29 PM.



Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
SEO by vBSEO 3.3.2