I have a Mini Cooper SD, Built Nov 2011. At about 21,000 (start of this month) the clutch started to slip. I'm now nearly at 23,000 and it's getting worse. It happens in 3rd,4th,5th and 6th. When I get to about 2,000 RPM, the rev's slips. It was first very intermittent, but its now progressively getting worse. Once it hits 2,000 RPM, it may slip to 2,800 then back down to 2,200 and catch on. Past couple of days, it's been getting to 2,000, going to 2,800/3,000, back down to 2,200, slipping again to 2,800 and back to 2,500.
I've rang my local Mini dealer, It's booked in Tuesday 29th. They have quoted me £127 per hour to just investigate the issue, and to see if it'll be covered under warranty. Very shocked about this.
I'm very doubtful it's anything to do with my driving. I've had 2 previous cars (Racked up 70k miles in one, 50k in the other) and never once had clutch issues. I drive on the motorway every day. I am concerned that I am the second owner (purchased it at 9,700 miles) and it was owned with lease company before (as I'm aware) so I'm wondering if that has something to do with it? (Previous drivers etc)
What can anyone recommend? What's the chances of this being covered under warranty?
I've phoned up some local garages, with quotes in the region of about £600 for just the clutch repair. I just don't want to spend a couple of hours at mini (so lets say £254 for 2 hours) then not get mini to fix (I don't fancy the expensive repair bill) and end up spending another £600 else where.
Hmmm, tricky. The clutch is a wear-and-tear item so it's never clear-cut.
I've read that Mini have had duff clutches in the past so a goodwill contribution from them may not be out of the question.
But equally, you don't know who had the car for half its life, so it's not like you can even guarantee that it wasn't operator abuse.
In your position, I would be pressing the dealer to get a substantial goodwill contribution from Mini, but I wouldn't think 100% was achievable unless a manufacturing defect could be proved - and I wouldn't bet on that if the clutch has survived for 20,000 miles so far.
If I got a Mini dealer to look at it, I would certainly want them to show me the clutch once apart, just to encourage them to believe they couldn't pull the wool over my eyes.
Might not 50% from Mini (not guaranteed) or £600 from a local independent come to the same thing?
Sorry not to be more positive, but I don't think you're in a strong position.
Hey, so I take it when they investigate, they will be actually taking the clutch out? Or am I wrong. They told me on the phone they expect it to take no longer than an hour to look at.
Also speaking with a mechanic earlier, he suggested the symptoms I'm showing is pointing more towards the DMF. How could the DMF of gone so soon? Surely that's not driver error? Blehhh I'm unsure what to do. I'm not sure who to take it too.
I'm based in Nottingham if anybody can recommend anybody local etc
Lots of posts about this issue on here and there have been various degrees of success in getting this covered/partly covered under warranty.
I went through a similar experience as you and after all was said and done Mini goodwilled the cost of the dual mass flywheel (approx. €550). The total cost of the clutch replacement including parts and labour at an authorized dealer will be roughly €1500-€1700. I ended up paying over €1000 out of my own pocket and was informed clutches are strictly wear items. Cost will be a good deal less at a decent independent shop.
The fact that it is already slipping as badly as you indicate means the entire clutch kit and flywheel will have to be replaced. You can safely assume the entire assembly is fit for scrap as the DMF will have heat spots on it by now and the friction disk is obviously gone. The cause (oil contamination, diver abuse) will only be determined with certainty after they drop the transmission and get to the bell-housing. Be aware that just getting to the clutch on these cars is minimum 4 hour job as the front of the car and subframe have to come out before any mechanic can get near the clutch. There are no inspection plates on these cars. Their estimate of "1 hour" is laughable - I was billed for 7-8 hours labour (3.5 to 4 hours disassembly and the same for reassably and they had the car for 2 full days). If I were you, I would ask them EXACTLY how they intend to investigate.
In my opinion, I suspect that the previous owner of the car abused the clutch and you've now been saddled with the result, probably the reason the car ended up for sale once they found out a clutch job was on the horizon. I suspect this will be your only point of argument that the clutch was in a poor state when you bought the car. Pretty near impossible for an experienced (or even inexperienced!) driver to ruin a clutch in such a short period of time. I would emphasize this point repeatedly with the shop.
I suggest you proceed first by arguing this should be under warranty (if you've had the car for less than 2 years) and then second by getting a very good idea of how they intend to assess the problem. If you are satisfied with their proposal, insist on having a signed work order from them showing exactly what you will be liable for in terms of diagnostic fees.
The AutoGuide.com network consists of the largest network of enthusiast-owned enthusiast-operated automotive communities.
AutoGuide.com provides the latest car reviews, auto show coverage, new car prices, and automotive news. The AutoGuide network operates more than 100 automotive forums where our users consult peers for shopping information and advice, and share opinions as a community.