MINI Cooper Forum banner
1 - 4 of 36 Posts

· Registered
Joined
·
895 Posts
Does the "left drift" exist you ask? or is it "left-pull" you mean?
Some people have become convinced that the left pull is a figment of their imagination that does not really exist. They have listened to people on the internet and some dealers who say that the problem only existed on a handful of cars and that the problem was of sub-standard component manufacture. Some dealers insist that they have never heard of the problem. They have simply popped a few tablets and happily driven off. I jest of course, because the reverse arguement is used by those whose cars steer as straight as an arrow, and they refuse to accept that the problem was widespread on earlier models.

Sadly many cars have been built with varying degrees of left pull and not just a drift.
Of course the car should be camber sensitive, but we are talking annoying tug, arm ache stuff on more extreme cars.

To address this problem BMW will happily fix these cars with steering pull provided you kick up a big fuss should the dealer try to play dumb. Don't get me wrong, not all dealers deny the existence of the pull. My dealer says that all the early models had a left pull to one degree or another. That's why my MINI is at the dealers right now getting a new front suspension system and is travelling back to the BMW plant at Thorne tomorrow to get the realignment done. If it was all psychological then it looks like I have even managed to convince BMW too.

Cars built week 9 and after have the fixed suspension. That does not mean that it will not pull if the alignment is out though, or if the tyre pressures are up the creak. Its just a lot less likely though.

If you want to test your sanity try the following:

Find a deserted stretch of flat, smooth, straight road, on a windless day.

Drive from North to South and note the steering pull (or a lesser drift).
Now drive South to North down the SAME wheel tracks.


If the car always goes East or always goes West then your car is doing what it is supposed to. If you don't like it, tough. Buy a different car coz it cant' be helped.

If it goes East and then West, or vice versa, then you had better make tracks to your dealer to fix it as your car has a pull in one direction.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
895 Posts
zoom180 said:


Don't know how to answer, but my build date is Feb 2000 if that helps. How about you Batman (and others)? And Apial, why do you ask? I know the fix is to the front struts, but are there more than one kind?
There have been at least 3 different front suspension struts in use. I have had all 3 types fitted, and only the latest type do the job satisfactorily. To check yours out have a look at Photographic evidence of Left Pull fix.

If you have the Mk1 or Mk2 type then the dealer will, after checking alignment etc, fit the Mk3 type.

Type 3 struts improve the handling by making it less twitchy/unstable as well as curing the pull, so you should have no worries.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
895 Posts
Well I've just swopped over MINI ONES with my brother to compare MK1 suspension with MK3.

I tried the MK1. The steering just wanted to pull itself into the left hand bends, but the right handers needed more steering effort.

The other thing is that I thought the road noise was louder too. On the straights it continued to tug to the left.

My brother immediately noticed the difference. Not only was it well balanced, but he also liked the smoother feel.:cool: He has headed off to his dealer to get his fixed. His MINI was a Nov 01 build car.Lets see if they try to fob him off!

I have now driven 4 out of 4 pre Nov 01 build cars that ALL pull to the left. Don't anyone tell me that they have a car that is pre-November build and it drives straight. I can't comment on the Dec,Jan,and Feb cars as I have'nt driven one, but I wouldn't be surprised if they are the same.

The problem is not a quality issue it is the design that is wrong. If you don't believe me, then go and drive a post-March build MINI with the MK3 struts. Then you'll realise the difference. BMW wouldn't go to the trouble of making 3 different front suspension types if it was not a design issue would they?

BMW can be relied upon to get it right eventually, unlike some other manufacturers who can't be bothered.

Well done BMW!
 
1 - 4 of 36 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top