MINI Cooper Forum banner

HAUNTED R52 - lots of Intermittent problems

1400 Views 5 Replies 4 Participants Last post by  JTownPBX
1. Radio won't power up for 2 minutes after starting.
2. Convertible top won't go up after starting, for 3-10 minutes. Goes down always. Goes up before I turn off car.
3. Heater blows no hot air, once a week, then works fine after for a long time.
4. Auto Trans acts like it's in neutral in the 1-2 shift, 2-3 shift twice a week. (sport drive makes no difference).
5. Once a month, when backing out of space, PS quits, sometimes Batt light comes on. NEVER happens going forward.

I'm getting real puzzled. All these systems seem un related. I'm guessing few if any vacuum servos any more, so maybe electrical? I know MAF or Vacuum often tells computer engine demand? I have a new battery (6 months old). I've had trans serviced, and they checked the electrical plugs for potential short. Doesn't seem to matter if wet, cold, dry or hot. Car always starts, other accessories always seem to work.

I've not pulled codes, but with so much affected weirdly (and had codes pulled at shop 6 months ago), I'm just scratching my head.
1 - 6 of 6 Posts
The heater not blowing hot air. If it is the 2nd generation mini cooper. You will be able to find some answers. If you have the IHKA climate control system(the system that lets you pick temp by degrees on a digital dash). Also in that case it can be a burned out heat element inside the thermostat housing; which would require an entire new thermostat housing which includes that item inbedded in it along with a new thermostat. One of main points to a 2nd generation cooling system is that it has THREE different methods of cooling the system.
1. The thermostat
2. The cooling fan
3. The heating element inside the thermostat housing.
The natural order of things inside cooling system as per the engine computer is
The heating element inside the thermostat housing. This element applies heat to the thermostat it self in order to open it up at a prescribe temperature according to the computer.
If this element fails it the car still stands a CHANCE of operating normal(more time than not without much a code fault). But one has to remember it is not correct to just let the thermostat open by its own thermo coil built into the thermostat. Although it is there for that reason so the car engine does not overheat.
Second in my opinion is the cooling fan. The cooling fan inside a Mini Cooper does not operate all the time. In fact. during operation of the car it will only come on for a brief instance. I mean like 3 seconds on a timer watch. This cooling fan is only gonna cool the coolant to temperature prescribed by the computer. The computer wants one temperature for the most part. Anything else is not really identifiable by the human diagnosis or operation of the car.
Meaning that it fluctuates rapid and not often.
Of course sometimes the fan will run after the car is shut off. Which is normal.
So with that in mind. The cooling system in my own opinion. Can get you down the road relatively safe. but in order to get the heat to work inside the car. It takes all of these components to be in operational condition. Without air bubbles of coolant in the system.
finally if you do have the IHKA climate control system. The heater core temperature sensor would be the final item to replace.
I realize it is a lot of stuff I have explained here. but don't fret to much over it. Once the components are replaced it will immediately start to work not really requiring any type of computer scan tool or anything else to erase codes if no codes were thrown.
Here is the thread I had on the final component.
See less See more
Check for dampness under the carpet in the front footwells. Make sure the BCU (in the footwell on the same side as the bonnet latch lever) is not wet. Problems with the BCU can cause random symptoms.
The heater not blowing hot air. If it is the 2nd generation mini cooper. You will be able to find some answers. If you have the IHKA climate control system(the system that lets you pick temp by degrees on a digital dash). Also in that case it can be a burned out heat element inside the thermostat housing; which would require an entire new thermostat housing which includes that item inbedded in it along with a new thermostat. One of main points to a 2nd generation cooling system is that it has THREE different methods of cooling the system.
1. The thermostat
2. The cooling fan
3. The heating element inside the thermostat housing.
The natural order of things inside cooling system as per the engine computer is
The heating element inside the thermostat housing. This element applies heat to the thermostat it self in order to open it up at a prescribe temperature according to the computer.
If this element fails it the car still stands a CHANCE of operating normal(more time than not without much a code fault). But one has to remember it is not correct to just let the thermostat open by its own thermo coil built into the thermostat. Although it is there for that reason so the car engine does not overheat.
Second in my opinion is the cooling fan. The cooling fan inside a Mini Cooper does not operate all the time. In fact. during operation of the car it will only come on for a brief instance. I mean like 3 seconds on a timer watch. This cooling fan is only gonna cool the coolant to temperature prescribed by the computer. The computer wants one temperature for the most part. Anything else is not really identifiable by the human diagnosis or operation of the car.
Meaning that it fluctuates rapid and not often.
Of course sometimes the fan will run after the car is shut off. Which is normal.
So with that in mind. The cooling system in my own opinion. Can get you down the road relatively safe. but in order to get the heat to work inside the car. It takes all of these components to be in operational condition. Without air bubbles of coolant in the system.
finally if you do have the IHKA climate control system. The heater core temperature sensor would be the final item to replace.
I realize it is a lot of stuff I have explained here. but don't fret to much over it. Once the components are replaced it will immediately start to work not really requiring any type of computer scan tool or anything else to erase codes if no codes were thrown.
Here is the thread I had on the final component.
My main point is that the cooling fan and the thermostat heating element lodged under the thermostat inside the thermostat housing are both computer controlled.
cooling fan and heater element work in tandem with each other and are only concerned with each other in the cooling system in a 2nd gen Mini cooper. All the other stuff is up to the person to service. And yes I have gone there with other coolant related issues, as far as the radiator itself. Getting clogged up over the years or heat soak worn out creating a improper temperature. a lot of it matters. But most important are those two items and a sealed system without air bubbles.
My main point is that the cooling fan and the thermostat heating element lodged under the thermostat inside the thermostat housing are both computer controlled.
cooling fan and heater element work in tandem with each other and are only concerned with each other in the cooling system in a 2nd gen Mini cooper. All the other stuff is up to the person to service. And yes I have gone there with other coolant related issues, as far as the radiator itself. Getting clogged up over the years or heat soak worn out creating a improper temperature. a lot of it matters. But most important are those two items and a sealed system without air bubbles.
An R52 is a first generation Mini not second.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
An R52 is a first generation Mini not second.
In that case it is not all bad. The blower fan is working!
1 - 6 of 6 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top